Entangled Pasts

This post provides teachers with insights into critically engaging with colonial histories through art, encouraging interdisciplinary collaboration and fostering student autonomy. It prompts reflection on pedagogical practices, including self-reflexivity, to empower educators to navigate complex topics with their students.

Entangled Pasts explores the connections between art and Britain’s colonial histories. It shows how important art was/is in maintaining imperial ideologies and practices as well as resisting and complicating them.

As an exhibition it also interrogates the role that institutions like the Royal Academy played. It forces questions about representation especially in relation to the violence inherent in the colonial project. It also implicates the viewer, asking questions about our own complicity and forcing a consideration of not just legacies but of duress. A. L. Stoler suggests that duress is found in the durabilities that colonial pasts produce; occluded histories, gradated sovereignties, affective security regimes, and “new” racisms, which carve out the distribution of inequities and deep fault lines of duress today.[1]

Bust in central hall, Royal Academy London, Entangled Pasts exhibition, 2024

The process of implication begins in the first room, the central hall. This is a space with high level roundels that enshrine eight busts, including ancients like Titian, da Vinci etc. through to members of the Academy like Christopher Wren. Its purpose is to suggest lineage, to build a ‘canon’. For this exhibition, four of the busts are behind mirrors. This provoked multiple thoughts for me, most immediately, that some canonical figures were being covered – a changing of the guard?  I saw myself. I was, like many of the non-white visitors, seen. Was I also being invited into the canon – a now fluid dynamic canon? But what was I seen doing? Passively viewing, consuming art, a bystander to contemporary duress.

The magnificent Hew Locke is the main draw in the next room. Here I ‘Armada’ as I think it does justice to the sense of movement the work engenders.

I think about 45 boats, rafts, ships of the line suspended in the gallery space heading in the same direction – where is unspecified. What we see is the past, floating alongside the present and perhaps heading to an unknown future. Here, I think duress is brought into plain sight where we can see one of the boats weighed down by other boats modelled on the Santa Maria and the Mayflower that relate stories of past ‘exploration’ to enduring stories of exploitation, refugees, and migration. The lack of people in the boats once again implicates us, the viewer. How does my personal history impact on the meaning making here? This includes how we relate to the title ‘Armada’ that stirs up Daily Mail headlines, small boats but also Elizbeth I or even D-Day.

Armada has been hung elsewhere but here it sits with a range of other paintings like the portrait of Dido Belle. So, as well as what the viewer brings, we now have how the setting and new juxtapositions create novel meanings and tensions. I was especially struck by Copley’s Watson and the Shark, which evoked for me the terrors that might lie below Locke’s brilliant armada.

Hew Locke "Armada", Royal Academy London, Entangled Pasts exhibition, 2024

Stuart Hall’s work has emphasised the intricate relationship between culture and power, highlighting its symbolic and institutional role in, politics, and education. Hall asserts that cultural pedagogy emerges from ongoing battles over representations, identifications, and agency. This battle is ongoing as recent research by the Runnymede Trust Race & inclusion in secondary school art education (runnymedetrust.org) reveals that less than 3% of artists names in GCSE art papers are from Black or South Asian backgrounds. Hall argued that a public pedagogy, as a struggle over identifications, is crucial to raising broader questions about how notions of difference, community, and belonging but also civic responsibility are produced ‘in specific historical and institutional sites within specific discursive formations and practices, by specific enunciative strategies’.[2] These sites include institutions like the RA but also school and examining bodies.

This exhibition has limitations. One Guardian review suggesting it shows the RA “all at sea with its risk-light colonial revisionism” – and its entry prices! But it offers visitors scope to think critically about how sites like the RA have functioned and continue to function using specific practices and strategies. It highlights the importance culture as part of a pedagogical practice especially in helping to understand colonial histories and offers scope for critical questions like – How does the artwork ‘Armada’ by Hew Locke bring the concept of duress into plain sight, and how does it engage with the past, present, and potentially an unknown future?  That in turn offers scope for thinking about civic responsibility and social change.

Considering Stuart Hall’s emphasis on public pedagogy as a struggle over identifications, this exhibition raises broader questions about social change and the production of these notions within specific historical and institutional contexts. I want to extend this analysis to think about the role of institutions like schools and other places of learning in shaping narratives related to colonial projects. How far might we be constructing problematic ‘canons’? How, if at all, do we explore the role of art in both maintaining and challenging imperial ideologies and practices?  In what ways can we collaborate across subjects to create a more interdisciplinary exploration of these themes? How might this approach enhance students’ understanding of the interconnectedness of different fields of study?

The questions raised extend beyond the examination of narratives (considered as substantive knowledge in teaching) to thinking about pedagogies. During my visit to ‘Entangled Pasts’ with two companions, including my colleague Dr Pen Woods, we each took different paths through the exhibition. At various points, we reconvened to focus on specific works, draw attention to noteworthy elements, ask questions, or share moments of excitement.

In our post-visit conversation, Pen highlighted how the exhibition served as a reminder for her that “learning is not a spectacle2. As a learner, I felt implicated, and this sense was facilitated by the exhibition’s curation, akin to how a teacher curates a curriculum. I was  also implicated in its pedagogy, with the central hall’s use of mirrors making our spectatorial presence and spectatorship visible and accountable to ourselves.

There was also room for me to bring my own preconceptions and experiences into play. The theme of the implicated subject became especially clear to me as I reflected on my recent viewing of “Zone of Interest”, which brought to mind Rothberg’s ideas about memory as a process of negotiation, cross-referencing, and borrowing.[3]

In navigating the exhibition, I had the autonomy to determine my route and co-construct meanings, emphasising the importance of self-reflexivity but also exploring this in dialogue with others. The exhibition invited me to (re)consider the intricate processes of knowledge (re)production by positioning me as an active learner engaged in the meaning-making process.

Teresa Strong Wilson’s work, drawing Pinar’s concept of ethical self-encounters and Rothberg’s thinking around memory, offers a consideration of how teachers might move from a consciousness as implicated subjects to being concerned subjects through a process of working through counter-stories and a shared subject matter.[4] This exhibition offers the possibilities of counter stories with a pedagogy of both accountability and agency.

NOTES

[1] A. L. Stoler, Duress: imperial durabilities in our times (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2016).

[2] Stuart Hall, “Introduction: Who Needs Identity?”, ed. S. Hall and Paul du Gay, Questions of Cultural Identity (Los Angeles, CA: Sage, 1996): 1-17: 4.

[3] M. Rothberg, Multidirectional memory: remembering the Holocaust in the age of decolonization (Stanford University Press, 2009).

[4] T. Strong-Wilson, Teachers’ ethical self-encounters with counter-stories in the classroom: from implicated to concerned subjects, 1st edn (New York: Routledge, 2021). W. Pinar, Educational experience as lived: knowledge, history, alterity: the selected works of William F. Pinar (New York and London, Routledge, 2015).